Nevada Stays Execution of Robert Lee McConnell for 2d Time

Robert Lee McConnell was set to die on February 1st at the hand of executioners for the state of Nevada, until yesterday when a federal court intervened, granting his motion to stay.  It's the second time that Mr. McConnell has faced that last walk -- he was previously set to be executed back in 2005.  Then, the execution was less than half-hour away when a stay was granted.  In 2005, McConnell had announced to everyone that he was ready to die. 

One wonders what that's like -- sitting on Death Row, being moved to the Carson City prison where Nevada kills its prisoners, setting your affairs in order and spending what you think are your last days on earth, only to find that they're not your last days.  Especially when it's happened to you twice.

Robert Lee McConnell took responsibility for a terrible mistake that he made when he murdered his ex-girlfriend's fiance back in 2002.  He pled guilty to the crime. 

Robert Lee McConnell also represented himself, both at trial and in this latest motion for stay.  In a request that exceeded 160 pages, McConnell asked Federal District Court Judge Robert Jones to halt the execution arguing in part that the death sentence was fundementally unfair.  (McConnell seems to be somewhat a jailhouse lawyer, having had his appeals to the Nevada Supreme Court heard - and rejected - last July, where he challenged the constitutionality of the lethal injection method of execution. )

Judge Jones has granted the stay, and ordered that McConnell have one month to file the appropriate petitions as well as having legal counsel appointed to assist him in that task. 

Of some note, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) was litigating the constitutionality of Nevada's lethal injection method of execution in 2007, and Nevada took the challenge seriously enough to stay the execution of William Castillo, a man who had asked for the death penalty. Nevada was planning on upping the drug cocktail to double the standard amount, as well as giving Castillo a mandatory sedative.  It was only when the ACLU dropped its suit that Nevada started back with capital punishment.  Castillo's case remains on appeal. (By the way, they call these folk "volunteers" when they want to die rather than live any longer in state imprisonment.  Chilling, isn't it?)

What McConnell will argue on his latest appeal will be interesting to follow. 

Not only does he (and his newly appointed counsel) have the recent ACLU challenge to reference, as well as whatever additional appellate points they will address, they also proceed in an environment where more and more people are recognizing that powerful, powerful reality: it is simply cheaper to allow prisoners like Mr. McConnell to remain behind bars than it is to continue with capital punishment.  

Trackbacks (0) Links to blogs that reference this article Trackback URL
Comments (6) Read through and enter the discussion with the form at the end
Joachim - January 19, 2010 6:18 PM


do you have a link to McDonnell's 160+ pages motion?


Terry - January 21, 2010 1:23 PM

Hi Joachim!

Good question, and no I don't. I surfed around a bit for the link, but didn't spend that much time on it. Maybe it's out there and I just didn't find it, or maybe the court clerk didn't spend the time to scan it and publish it online. Don't know.

Hope you're having a great day! How's the blogging going? See you on Twitter, my friend,

Bob - February 1, 2010 9:15 AM

You left out the quote from an interview prior to his execution date where he said his only regret was killing his ex's fiance and not her. He said "I wouldn't play around and have feelings like I did the last time. I wouldn't let her get away. She would be tortured and killed."

You also failed to mention that McConnell voluntarily gave up his appeals, but resumed them an hour before his scheduled execution in 2005.

Here is what you called a mistake. After being fired from his job after his arrest for violating his ex-girlfriends PPO, he vowed revenge. He shot her fiance nine times, tried to dig out some of the bullets from his body, then stabbed the corpse in the chest with a steak knife. He then waited for his ex girlfriend, handcuffed her, raped her, and kidnapped her.

Try telling the whole story next time, this blog you posted makes you look disingenuous atbest.

Ms. June - July 26, 2010 11:23 PM

He flat out needs to pay the price..let us get
on with it..over and done !!

ronnie rose - May 28, 2011 5:33 PM

I hope he gets what he desirves..the death penalty!
no mercy for him!

Tbruce - June 26, 2012 9:38 PM

I have known Rob since 1998 when this happened it shocked me. I was in disbelief. I even room mated with him years ago. All I want to know is he still alive?

Post A Comment / Question Use this form to add a comment to this entry.

Remember personal info?
Send To A Friend Use this form to send this entry to a friend via email.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...